UH-OH! — The Evolutionary Problem Not Even Darwin Could Get Past
(12:02 VIEWING) — Who made the following statements?
“As according to the theory of Natural Selection an interminable number of intermediate forms must have existed … why is not every geological formation charged with such links?”
“The abrupt manner in which whole groups of species suddenly appear in certain formations has been urged by several paleontologists … as a fatal objection to the belief in the transmutation of species. If numerous species … have really started into life all at once, that fact would be fatal to the theory.”
“I can answer these questions and objections only on the supposition that the geological record is far more imperfect than most geologists believe …Only a small portion of the world has been geologically explored.”
This will come as a shock to more than a few readers, but all three of those statements were made by Charles Darwin, the father of modern evolutionary theory and its claim that new species evolve over time through numerous small changes that ultimately result in something all together different.

Darwin’s response to the paleontology argument was basically to hope future geological discoveries would vindicate him.
The following 12:02 video produced jointly by the Discovery Institute and Lukas Reugger of Deflate Youtube channel fame addresses what is in some respects the still-biggest challenge to the conventional wisdom of modern evolutionary theory:
If new species don’t appear suddenly but rather evolve through multiple minor changes that at some point cumulatively result in a new species, then why don’t we see much more evidence of such a piece-by-piece process in the fossil record?
Instead, we see the Cambrian Explosion in which millions of new species suddenly and in fully recognizable form appeared. The following video can open up whole new vistas of intellectual and scientific inquiry for those with open minds:
Am I following? Nope.
I’m not a Creationist as such, although I respect Creationists. Although the account in Genesis is not a literal description of how humans appeared, it is Philosophically true, in that ideas like being made in the image of God, having eaten the fruit of the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil, being born into sin and so on, are profoundly true.
Darwin’s theory, on the other hand, Evolution of Species by Natural Selection, was and remains very good science, but is far narrower than most laypeople understand; and the Philosophical inferences that have been drawn from it over the years range from overstated to abhorrent — it is scientifically useful in its own narrow field (like most science), but it answers none of the most important scientific questions (such as how did life arise, how does life differ from non-life, what gives rise to consciousness, and what makes Man different from the Animals), nor any Philosophical questions at all.
The answers we really need in daily life remain the domain of Philosophers, and probably always will. Despite its extreme age (especially Genesis II & III; I was told Genesis I is a slightly later revelation), and its brevity, the Biblical ‘Vision of Creation’ is still the best Philosophical description we have, which supports the view of most of the world’s population that it was a Divine Vision.
Why does every one of these claims about flaws in evolutionary theory sound like it was written by somebody whose knowledge of the field dates to the mid-1800s?
The Cambrian “explosion” is now known to have spanned around 25,000,000 years — plenty of time for new forms to evolve by variation and selection, but the known record is very scattered, and many of the details have been lost to time. And modern paleontology has found lots of intermediate forms, from almost every group of organisms known. That was true even the last time I was reasonably up on the field’s newest discoveries, and that was twenty years ago. A lot more has been found since then.
Oh, and the use of pseudo-taxonomic terms such as “fully formed and recognizable species” in the above piece is clearly intended to obfuscate, not educate. First, every species that is defined is recognizable as distinct from every other species — if it’s not, then it’s not a valid species. That’s how taxonomy works. Second, when have we ever found a species in the fossil record — or anywhere else — that was not “fully formed”? What do you expect to find as an intermediate between (for example) dinosaur and bird? A “monopterosaurus” with one standard-issue theropod arm and one standard-issue bird’s wing?
How about sharing with us three recent examples from modern paleontology of intermediate forms, say of the Polar Bear, the Bald Eagle, and the squirrel?
Polar bear: https://evolution.berkeley.edu/evo-news/one-small-fossil-one-giant-step-for-polar-bear-evolution/
Bald eagles can’t be specifically distinguished in the fossil record, because they are identified by color — something that doesn’t fossilize under most conditions. The sea-eagles as a group are thought to date back around thirty million years, with the nearest known fossil to the bald eagle being around a million years old. Bald eagles are considered a “species pair” with the white-tailed eagle, meaning that you can’t always reliably distinguish them from each other, even using DNA analysis. In other words, the bald eagle and white-tailed eagle are in the process of speciation right now. And will be for quite a while: as slow-breeding species with few selective pressures on them, these eagles don’t evolve very fast.
As for squirrels, which of the two-hundred-odd species of squirrel are you referring to?
Thank you very much for pointing out these examples.The Polar Bear and Eagle examples make logical sense IF you assume the evolutionary structure as the explanation for the characteristics described. My point in response is illustrated in this quote from the Polar Bear piece you linked: Polar bears, it turns out, may have evolved surprisingly quickly in response to past climactic changes. Here, we’ll examine the different lines of evidence that led scientists to this conclusion. By the author’s own description, the evidence linked to the jawbone MAY indicate a faster-than-expected evolutionary process, but that’s not conclusive, it’s a speculative theory derived from the presupposition. Note, please, I am not saying conclusively that the jawbone does NOT point to such speculation. But speculation is not science, it’s speculative (and I intend no subjective tone in using that word, which indicates thinking about, assessing, considering possibilities).